Close Menu
saiphnews.comsaiphnews.com

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Jasprit Bumrah OUT, Kuldeep Yadav and Arshdeep Singh IN: India’s predicted playing XI for 5th Test vs England at The Oval | Cricket News

    July 30, 2025

    Brown University Makes a Deal With the White House to Restore Funding

    July 30, 2025

    Rose Leiman Goldemberg, 97, Dies; Her ‘Burning Bed’ Was a TV Benchmark

    July 30, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    saiphnews.comsaiphnews.com
    Wednesday, July 30
    • Home
    • Finance
    • Sports
    • Health

      Fuel Your Workout: 15 Powerful Fitness Motivation Quotes to Keep You Going

      May 15, 2025

      Sizzle Away the Pounds: The Ultimate Guide to Fat-Burning Workouts

      May 14, 2025

      Kickstart Your Fitness Journey: The Ultimate Beginner Workout Guide

      April 30, 2025

      Get Fit Anytime, Anywhere: The Top 10 Fitness Apps You Need to Download Now

      April 30, 2025

      Unlocking Wellness: 10 Essential Habits for a Healthier Life

      April 22, 2025
    • Media & Culture
      1. World
      2. Politics
      3. Health
      4. View All

      Protests in Waterlooville against new homes for asylum seekers

      July 30, 2025

      The London chip shop where the food is made from hand-sewn felt

      July 30, 2025

      The Difference Between M.D. and D.O. Degrees

      July 30, 2025

      County Championship: Lyth century puts Yorkshire in control over Sussex

      July 30, 2025

      Jasprit Bumrah OUT, Kuldeep Yadav and Arshdeep Singh IN: India’s predicted playing XI for 5th Test vs England at The Oval | Cricket News

      July 30, 2025

      Brown University Makes a Deal With the White House to Restore Funding

      July 30, 2025

      Doctors union agrees to resume talks with Streeting

      July 30, 2025

      Can Ireland deliver on €112bn schemes?

      July 30, 2025

      Fuel Your Workout: 15 Powerful Fitness Motivation Quotes to Keep You Going

      May 15, 2025

      Sizzle Away the Pounds: The Ultimate Guide to Fat-Burning Workouts

      May 14, 2025

      Kickstart Your Fitness Journey: The Ultimate Beginner Workout Guide

      April 30, 2025

      Get Fit Anytime, Anywhere: The Top 10 Fitness Apps You Need to Download Now

      April 30, 2025

      India’s Cultural Mosaic: A Deep Dive into the Rich Tapestry of Traditions and Modernity

      May 23, 2025

      India-Focused Headlines

      May 22, 2025

      Tradition Meets Technology: How Modern India is Redefining Ancient Rituals

      May 15, 2025

      Global Canvas: Exploring the Latest Trends in International Art Exhibitions

      May 15, 2025
    • National
    • Politics
    • Tech
    • Contact us
    saiphnews.comsaiphnews.com
    Home » Cultural appropriation isn’t just colonial, it’s casteist
    Uncategorized

    Cultural appropriation isn’t just colonial, it’s casteist

    saiphnewsBy saiphnewsJuly 4, 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


    When Italian luxury house Prada recently unveiled its version of the Kolhapuri chappal, Indian social media was quick to react. Accusations of cultural appropriation and erasure followed, accompanied by demands for proper attribution and a wider call to “decolonise fashion”. But what if the cultural erasure didn’t start with Prada, or with the West? What if the deeper, older story is not just about colonial appropriation, but about caste-based appropriation from within? Beneath the Indian diaspora’s outrage lies a deeper, more uncomfortable truth: the issue isn’t just about what is being borrowed, but who gets to borrow and who doesn’t. The Kolhapuri controversy exposes not only colonial legacies but also the casteist dynamics embedded within India’s cultural economy.

    An artisan does stitching work inside her house  in Kolhapur

    An artisan does stitching work inside her house in Kolhapur
    | Photo Credit:
    EMMANUAL YOGINI

    Not just Indian, but Dalit in origin

    Originating in Maharashtra’s Kolhapur region and its neighbouring districts, the Kolhapuri chappal is known for its durability and distinct structure. What is less commonly discussed is who makes them. Historical accounts of Kolhapuri craftsmanship often mention specific sub-castes such as the Chamar, Dhor, and Matang: scheduled caste communities historically assigned the task of leatherwork, a practice stigmatised due to its contact with animal hides.

    These artisans, often from marginalised backgrounds, tan, dye, and stitch the leather by hand, creating a product celebrated for its durability and aesthetic. Yet, mainstream narratives often generalise Kolhapuris as a “Maharashtrian” or “Indian” craft, erasing the caste-specific labour behind them.

     Artisans making kolhapuri chappals inside a Igna Leathers  workshop  in Kolhapur

    Artisans making kolhapuri chappals inside a Igna Leathers workshop in Kolhapur
    | Photo Credit:
    EMMANUAL YOGINI

    Appropriation marketed as “revival”

    Within India, cultural appropriation often wears the mask of reverence. Many Indian artforms, textiles, jewellery, and crafts originate from Dalit-Adivasi aesthetics, labour, and design but commercialised by upper caste (Savarna) owned businesses. When a luxury Indian label collaborates with artisans, it is seen as uplifting tradition. But these collaborations rarely involve co-authorship or equity. Artisans are paid per piece. Designs are owned by the brand. The origin story is softened into a marketing stunt. While artisans toil for minimal wages, the profits and prestige accrue to brands. Artisans, often from marginalised social backgrounds, form the backbone of India’s handicraft sector but lack control over branding or distribution. Savarna designers and brands act as gatekeepers, curating and profiting from these crafts while framing their role as “saviours of craft”.

    An artisan polishes a kolhapuri chappal inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur

    An artisan polishes a kolhapuri chappal inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur
    | Photo Credit:
    EMMANUAL YOGINI

    Who owns the means of design?

    Indian fashion runways feature designers predominantly from Savarna castes. The narratives in Indian fashion are largely shaped by editorials run by upper-caste surnames. The leadership roles in the Indian fashion and textile sector are disproportionately represented by upper castes. Meanwhile, Bahujans remain largely invisible in decision-making roles, often limited to labour roles. Their labour, when filtered through a Savarna designer’s lens, becomes “art.” When done independently, it remains “ethnic” or “rural.”

    Visitors shop Kolhapuri chappals  inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur

    Visitors shop Kolhapuri chappals inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur
    | Photo Credit:
    EMMANUAL YOGINI

    Many traditional artisans lack access to formal design education, capital investment, or English-language fluency. Such barriers make it difficult for Bahujans to participate in the elite circuits of fashion. Bahujans are often reduced to tokenistic roles: a one season’s showstopper or a lookbook model, to signal performative inclusivity without ceding power. Bahujans are rarely seen in leadership roles, such as creative directors or brand owners, yet their identity is exploited in marketing campaigns that romanticise their poverty and struggles as “hardwork” or “heritage.” This tokenism commodifies Bahujan struggle while denying them agency, perpetuating a cycle where their labour is celebrated, but their voices are silenced.

    The diaspora and the blind spot

    The Indian diaspora’s calls to decolonise fashion often overlook these internal caste hierarchies. This blind spot is telling. National pride tends to eclipse caste critique. In calling out foreign appropriation, many forget to examine who within India controls narrative, capital, and authorship. The act is the same. The reaction shifts from outrage to celebration depending on who borrows and who gets to author the narrative.

    Visitors shop Kolhapuri Chappals  inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur

    Visitors shop Kolhapuri Chappals inside a store in Chappal market in Kolhapur
    | Photo Credit:
    EMMANUAL YOGINI

    What cultural equity actually requires

    The question isn’t whether Kolhapuris or any Indian craft should evolve. They must. But the more urgent question is: who gets to decide how they evolve? Who profits? Who gets cited in design schools and magazines, and who remains a footnote? True cultural equity is about fair wages, credit, representation in leadership roles and platforms for co-authorship in design and storytelling which rebalance historic exclusion.

    The Prada-Kolhapuri controversy is more than a clash over sandals; it’s a mirror reflecting how global and local systems both flatten the histories of marginalised makers while uplifting those with socio-economic capital. Within the Indian fashion ecosystem, the intersections of caste and class dictate who gets to be the “designer” and who remains the uncredited, underpaid and exploited “artisan.” Until credit, compensation, and representation are equitably shared, cultural appropriation — whether by Prada or privileged Indian elites — will remain a form of theft, rooted in both colonial and casteist legacies.

    The writer is a Chennai based fashion designer, artist and educator

    Published – July 04, 2025 05:02 pm IST


    Share this:

    • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
    • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

    Like this:

    Like Loading...
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    saiphnews
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Badly behaved tourists crowd safari parks. How do you stop them from taking selfies with the lions?

    July 30, 2025

    Sanjay Garg, Hanut Singh and India Art Fair to host Incandescent 2.0 in Hyderabad

    July 30, 2025

    Farak to champion eco streetwear at CDC Finals, Lakmé Fashion Week

    July 30, 2025
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Our Picks
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    Don't Miss

    Jasprit Bumrah OUT, Kuldeep Yadav and Arshdeep Singh IN: India’s predicted playing XI for 5th Test vs England at The Oval | Cricket News

    National July 30, 2025

    Kuldeep Yadav (Getty Images) NEW DELHI: India and England are set to face off in…

    Share this:

    • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
    • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

    Like this:

    Like Loading...

    Brown University Makes a Deal With the White House to Restore Funding

    July 30, 2025

    Rose Leiman Goldemberg, 97, Dies; Her ‘Burning Bed’ Was a TV Benchmark

    July 30, 2025

    Doctors union agrees to resume talks with Streeting

    July 30, 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

    Our Mission
    Our Mission

    At Saiph News, we are dedicated to delivering the latest updates from across the globe, with a strong focus on National News, International Affairs, Health, Politics, Stock Market Trends, and more. Our mission is to keep our readers informed, engaged, and empowered with factual reporting and insightful analysis.

    Email Us: saiphtech247@gmail.com

    Our Picks
    Subscribe Us For Latest Updates
    Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
    Loading
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Terms & Conditions
    © 2025 Saiph News. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    %d